This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
Supply House Times logo Supply House Times
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Supply House Times logo Supply House Times
  • Home
  • Magazine
    • Issues
    • Digital Editions
    • Archives
    • Ad Index
    • B.I.G Book
    • Rep Locator
  • Market Sectors
    • Plumbing
    • Bath & Kitchen
    • Industrial PVF
    • Radiant/Hydronics
    • HVAC
    • Fire Protection
    • Solar Thermal/Geothermal
    • Technology
    • Codes
    • Company News
    • ASA News
    • Women in Industry
  • Columnists
    • Mike Miazga: From the Editor
    • Dan Holohan: Heating Help
    • Hank Darlington: Showrooms
    • Jim Wheeler: HVAC
    • Bruce Merrifield: Distribution
    • Dirk Beveridge: Innovation Strategies
    • Michael Mercer: The Dr.’s Office
    • Letter from ASA President
    • Safety Columnists
  • Multimedia
    • Photo Gallery
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • YouTube Channel
    • eBook
  • Special Editions
    • Premier 150
    • PVF Outlook
    • PB Outlook
    • Radiant Comfort Guide
    • Radiant & Hydronics Report
    • Green Plumbing & Heating
  • Products
  • More
    • Industry Calendar
    • Classified Ads
    • Industry Links
    • Custom Content & Marketing Services
    • Market Research
    • eNewsletters
    • Showrooms
    • Supply House Times Store
  • Bath & Kitchen Pro
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Home » How to heat old churches
Dan Holohan: Heating HelpMarket SectorsColumnistsRadiant/HydronicsHVAC

How to heat old churches

In an attempt to prevent additional church-heating-related conundrums, I give you this.

Holohan
June 29, 2015
Dan Holohan
KEYWORDS heating / hydronic systems / hydronics / PHCP Distributors / radiators
Reprints
No Comments

A few issues ago I wrote about the chaos caused by installing motorized zone valves in older steam-heating systems found in places of worship.

In an attempt to prevent additional church-heating-related conundrums, I give you this:

The Lovely Marianne and I attend Catholic mass at a lovely church that rose from fertile Long Island soil in 1924.

The parishioners did nearly all of the construction, which tells you something about both those days and how people have changed. The roof of the church is laced with thick brown beams, all in line and meant to resemble the upturned hull of a schooner, Long Island, being just that, and many of those parishioners being fishermen. It’s quite beautiful.

And it being 1924, the men who built the church chose to heat it with steam, which used to make me smile as I sat through homilies, listening to both our pastor and what sounded like Satan hammering away inside the pipes. You can’t fix faulty steam traps with prayer.

When 1995 arrived, contractors rather than parishioners showed up and expanded the old church, turning the inverted schooner into a cruciform and making room for more of the faithful.

They tore out the old Warren Webster steam system and replaced it with a tiled, radiant floor. It was a nice change and it cut the parish’s fuel bills in half, even though the church now had nearly twice as much floor space as it had in 1924. This was possible because, with radiant heating, the air stays at a fairly constant temperature from floor to ceiling. There are few convective air currents in a radiantly heated building, and this is especially important in any building that’s as lofty as a church.

Liverpool, England, the birthplace of modern hydronic radiant heating, has a famous cathedral that looks as if it’s been there since King Arthur, but don’t be fooled. They built that gorgeous cathedral between 1920 and 1961, with an understandable hiatus for World War II. It, too, has a radiant floor, but hot air, not warm water, directed through buried channels, heats that stone floor; and it’s a fine place to consider the concept of convection. During the heating season, the air temperature 4 ft. above the Liverpool Cathedral’s floor is 60°F, while the air temperature at the clerestory, 97 ft. above the floor is 58.5°F. A very slight difference, indeed.

In 1897, Englishman Walter Jones wrote a book for American contractors. He called it, simply, “Hot Water Manual,” and his purpose was to compare British and American ways of heating buildings at that time, and in the times preceding. He was a lover of hot-water heating and speaks not exactly enthusiastically about steam heat, which was strictly an American thing back then.

When it came to churches on both sides of the ocean, he wrote: “One of the greatest difficulties is to prevent down draughts of currents of cold air, and this tendency exists in all lofty buildings, whether they are heated by high- or low-pressure hot water, by steam, or by hot air. The greater the difference between the inside and the outside air temperature, so, in proportion, will the tendency to down draughts be increased.

“The higher the temperature of the pipes or the hot air, the stronger will be the currents; hence the low-pressure system is the best, because a larger heating surface is presented at a milder or more humid temperature. You may frequently see persons looking up at the roof, ceiling or windows to find where the draught comes from, when the cause is from a totally different source. If the pipes are intensely hot, the currents of heated air will ascend more rapidly, and displace in the same relative proportion the cooler air in the upper part of the building, and these currents are very objectionable.”

When Mr. Jones writes of low-pressure systems, he also means low temperature. I thought back to our church’s old Warren Webster steam system. Those radiators were hot but each radiator had a box built around it. The old church was crowded and people often stood in the aisles. Those near the radiators put their coats on top of the boxes, but that’s not why those boxes were there.

When you place a solid barrier such as a shelf or the top of a wooden box over the top of a radiator, you cut the radiator’s output by about 30% because you’re impeding the convective movement of air. This also means the air won’t rise as high within the church as it would had the boxes not been there.

 

No fan of ceiling fans

Let’s fast-forward to the 1970s. OPEC got our attention in ’73 with its first oil embargo. If you’re old like me you’ll remember how we got to know our neighbors better by fighting with them as they tried to cut into those long lines approaching gas stations.

And it wasn’t just the gasoline that got expensive; the price of heating oil and natural gas also soared. Churches and other lofty houses of worship were especially affected because the faithful put less money in the baskets during those tough times. So the clergy looked for solutions and one of those solutions seemed to be the ceiling fan.

Actually, more than one ceiling fan. Someone told the clergy that heat rises, which it doesn’t. Hot air rises. There’s a difference. Consider that beautiful cathedral in Liverpool, England. Up near those high windows, 97 ft. above the floor, the air temperature is only 1 1/2 degrees cooler than it is 4 ft. above the floor. Air won’t rise unless you heat it, and a floor radiant system doesn’t heat the air; it only heats the people.

But the clergy didn’t know that during the late 70s, so lots of ceiling fans went into to those lofty buildings in an attempt to bring down the hot air. But when the clergy hit the switch, the fans began to take what was actually relatively cold air up near the ceiling and mix it into the relatively warm air that was down there with the people. That lowered the overall air temperature within the building, which caused the thermostat to keep the burner running. Naturally, the fuel bills increased.

This is why, if you are of the faithful, you will never see those fans running during the winter. You’ll see them on only during the summer.

And since I learned about this, I’ve heard from contractors who had the opportunity to replace boilers in old churches. These folks are professionals, so if it’s a steam system they go around and measure all the radiators and check out the piping for the proper pickup factor. That’s the only proper way to size a replacement steam boiler. If it’s a hot-water job, they do an accurate heat-loss calculation on the building.

But then they call me because they learn that the boiler and radiation that have been in that old church for 100 years or so is too small to heat the building, even though it’s been heating the building for all that time.

And to understand why this is, we have to hark back to Mr. Jones and other writers of heating textbooks back in the 1890s when all this was new. Contractors in those days took the advice of the book writers and sized the heating system to be relatively low temperature and smaller than the actual heat loss of the building.

They wanted to heat people without creating convective drafts within the building. They deliberately undersized the boiler and radiators, which leaves the modern contractor with some sphincter-puckering decisions to make.

But that’s the secret to heating old churches.  

A floor radiant system doesn’t heat air, it only heats people.

 

 

sht-subscribe

Recent Articles by Dan Holohan

Dan Holohan: A foreign exchange

Dan Holohan: Your customers' pet peeves

Dan Holohan: Saving coal at home

Dan Holohan: To teach is to sell

Dan Holohan: Does it pay to fix those steam traps

Holohan

Dan is the hydronics contributing editor for Supply House Times. He operates the popular www.HeatingHelp.com web site where you'll find just that - Heating Help. Post your technical challenges on The Wall bulletin board and get input from some of the best in the business. You can reach him at dan@heatinghelp.com. He loves hearing from you!

Related Articles

Dan Holohan: How to feed a low-pressure steam boiler

How the low-water cutoff came to be

How to kill a boiler

A look at how radiators were rated

Related Products

Supply House Time Manufacturers Reps Directory

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • Print & Digital Edition Subscriptions
  • eNewsletters
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service

More Videos

Popular Stories

First Supply acquires lighting store

Oatey acquires certain assets of The Keeney Mfg. Co.

First Supply acquires lighting store

Ferguson Ventures invests in Whisker Labs and Ting technology

Milwaukee Tool

The value of independent manufacturers reps

Northeastern

Northeastern Supply continues its expansion

dodge outlook 2020 report

Construction starts to slip back in 2020

SHTPremier150-360


sht-young-execs-360

Events

June 5, 2019

Do You Know Everything You Need to Know About North American Drinking Water Laws?

On Demand Protecting drinking water is of paramount importance.  The last decade has seen the enactment of safe drinking water laws that safeguard our water for consumption.  These laws can lead to confusion in determining which applications are regulated and which materials are safe to be installed in these applications. 

December 30, 2030

Webinar Sponsorship Information

For webinar sponsorship information, visit www.bnpevents.com/webinars or email webinars@bnpmedia.com.

View All Submit An Event

Products

Valve Handbook, 3rd Edition

Valve Handbook, 3rd Edition

Revised to include details on the latest technologies, Valve Handbook, Third Edition, discusses design, performance, selection, operation, and application. This updated resource features a new chapter on the green technology currently employed by the valve industry, as well as an overview of the major environmental global standards that process plants are expected to meet.

See More Products

SHT-Meet20Women-360

Supply House Times

SHT 1119 cover

2019 November

Check out November issue of Supply House Times features a chat with incoming ASA President Bill Glockner of Hirsch Pipe & Supply, plus a complete recap of ASA’s NETWORK2019 50th anniversary celebration. We also have the latest tool trends and a look at how Milwaukee Tool best utilizes its network of independent manufacturers reps.

View More Create Account
  • Additional Links
    • Ad Index
    • List Rental
    • Order Reprints
    • Web Exclusives
    • Supply House Times Store
    • Bath & Kitchen Pro
    • Contact Us
    • eNewsletters
    • Privacy Policy
  • Want More?
    • Connect
    • Industry Links
    • Survey And Sample
  • Plumbing Group
    • Plumbing & Mechanical
    • PM Engineer

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing